The debate around Ruben Amorim and whether he is the right man to take Manchester United forward continues to rumble on. Some fans still question his decisions, especially when it comes to young players.
His handling of Kobbie Mainoo has often been criticised, with many believing the midfielder should be trusted more.
However, while doubts remain in some areas, Amorim has clearly helped unlock the best version of another young talent at Old Trafford. That player is Amad Diallo.
Once on the fringes under Erik ten Hag, Amad has now become one of the most important players in Amorim’s system.
However, despite his rise, fresh competition could soon arrive, putting his long-term role under real pressure.
Amad’s Journey From Fringes to First Choice
Not long ago, Amad’s United career looked stuck. Under Erik ten Hag, he often found himself watching from the bench, even when the team needed creativity and energy.
One moment that still frustrates fans came in a European away game when Ten Hag chose Antony ahead of him, only turning to Amad late on after an injury.
At the time, the manager spoke about training performances, but many supporters felt Amad was being unfairly ignored. Since Amorim’s arrival, that story has completely changed.
Amad is now a regular starter. He has played more minutes than most of the squad under the new manager and has become a key part of the system. His pace, movement and bravery on the ball have added something United badly needed.
He has also contributed with goals and assists, helping the team in key matches and challenging moments.
Still, while his impact has been clear, the numbers show there is room for more improvement.
Strong Trust, But Not Perfect Output
This season, Amad has started regularly in the Premier League, often playing as a right wing-back or sometimes in a more central attacking role.
He even scored in the recent wild draw against Bournemouth before heading off for international duty.
However, despite the trust from Amorim, his output has been mixed. A couple of goals and assists across many starts is decent, but not explosive.
For a player in attacking areas, United will want more end product over time.
There have also been concerns about his defensive side. Amad works hard, but his slight frame can be exposed.
At times this season, he has been beaten at the far post or pushed off the ball by stronger opponents.
In a system that demands discipline and balance, that is something Amorim cannot ignore.
This is where the latest transfer talk becomes very interesting.
footballfancast.com
United Step Up Interest in Antoine Semenyo
Manchester United are now strongly linked with Antoine Semenyo, the powerful Bournemouth attacker who has impressed many this season.
Reports suggest United are already holding talks and are seriously considering a move in January.
Semenyo, who plays for AFC Bournemouth, is said to be open to a move to Old Trafford. His contract reportedly includes a release clause worth around £65m, and United are weighing up whether to activate it.
What makes Semenyo attractive is his versatility. He can play on either wing, through the middle, or even as an attacking wing-back.
That flexibility fits perfectly with Amorim’s system, which demands players who can adapt quickly and do both sides of the game.
According to respected transfer insider Fabrizio Romano, United are not alone. Manchester City and Liverpool are also monitoring the situation closely. That means United may need to move fast if they want to win the race.
Why Semenyo Could Change the Balance
While Amad has flair and creativity, Semenyo brings power, strength and directness.
He is difficult to knock off the ball and causes defenders real problems with his pace and physical style.
This season, he has already delivered strong goal and assist numbers, proving he can make a difference in the final third.
He is also comfortable using both feet, which makes him unpredictable and hard to defend against.
Defensively, Semenyo offers something Amad struggles to provide. He wins aerial duels, tracks back well, and is not easily beaten one-on-one. For a manager like Amorim, who wants balance and structure, that profile is very appealing.
That does not mean Amad would be pushed out straight away. There is a real chance the two could play on opposite sides, giving United pace, power and skill across the pitch.
But if Amorim wants to make it a direct competition for one role, Semenyo’s all-around game could give him the edge.
What This Means for Amad’s Future
Amad’s progress under Amorim should not be ignored. He has worked hard to earn his place and has delivered in important moments.
His link-up play with Bryan Mbeumo has been one of United’s brighter attacking combinations.
But at a club like Manchester United, comfort does not exist. Every position is under review, and every player must keep improving.
The possible arrival of Semenyo would send a clear message. Amorim wants competition.
He wants players who can deliver every week, at both ends of the pitch. If Amad wants to remain a key man beyond 2026, he will need to raise his level again.
Ruben Amorim’s reign is still being judged, but one thing is clear: he is not afraid to make big calls. He revived Amad’s career, and now he may test him with serious competition.
Semenyo’s potential arrival would not mean Amad has failed. Instead, it would show that United are trying to build a stronger, more balanced squad.
For Amad, the challenge is simple, keep improving, stay brave, and prove he belongs at the heart of United’s future.
The next transfer window could be a defining moment for both players and for Amorim’s long-term project at Old Trafford.
For more Manchester United News, follow us on Facebook for instant updates directly to your phone.
Discover more from MUFCNews
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
